Herbert har en vill fantasi i dette sci-fi-eposet, og jeg føler virkelig jeg kan se for meg hvordan planetene ser ut, hvordan menneskene ser ut - hverdagen som beskrives blir nærmest naturlig etter hvert.

Når det er sagt, så slet jeg meg gjennom Dune. Jeg leste, la den bort, leste la den bort, og de siste 3-400 sidene leste jeg på ren vilje. Boka går svært sakte framover, og historien mister en del moment i de kronglete beskrivelsene som gjentar seg selv alt for ofte. Jeg skjønte hvor blå-blå øynene til Fremen-folket er, og hvor hvit Crysknifen er, første gangen det ble beskrevet.

Jeg begynte rett og slett å kjede meg, og jeg ble på ingen måte forløst av slutten. Jeg synes det er greit å ha lest boka, for å kunne ha en egen mening om den, og for faktisk å si at jeg har lest et av verdens største sci-vi-verk, men det stopper egentlig der.

Ei godt konstruert fantasyverd, men denne boka blei altfor tørr for meg.

OBS: omtalen under er på engelsk. Jeg håper ikke det bryter med noen regler. Jeg kan nok få skrevet en norsk omtale på et eller annet tidspunkt, men akkurat nå føler jeg at jeg sa det jeg trengte i den engelske omtalen min på goodreads. Så her er den:

I gave this book five stars/terningkast seks - but I was still a bit disappointed with it. (OOPS: SPOILERS AHEAD)

When I begun reading, it had everything: I was immersed instantly. The writing was superb, it had philosophy, it had shades of grey.

But throughout the book I realized this was not the revolutionary sci-fi-book I had hoped for. It was not a book that dared to confront the status quo, that dared to defy authority the way I had hoped - the way I felt it was building towards.

Paul's goal is not to fight for freedom for the Fremen - but to rule them, unquestioningly, and to secure the throne. He does not defy the authority of the Empire on Arrakis, he does not say to the fremen: I lead you now, but our goal is freedom and equality for all men. And we will all rule together. Instead he says: you are mine. He does not overturn the notion that not all humans are human.

In the beginning, I thought it would be a book like that. That we would see a fight for an Arrakis free of the Empire, free from fiefdom. A free Arrakis, with a free people. But unfortunately the book disappointed me in that regard.

The reason I still give it five stars is because it's so damn well written, and the story it tells - although a different story than I had hoped for - is grand. And in many ways, the fact that it DOESN'T tell the story I wanted it to is an advantage aswell - Paul is human, so very human, and flawed. And throughout this book you can clearly see criticism of religion, criticism of putting one person on a pedestal as a natural leader. Paul claims he wants to avoid a jihad with him as the prophet that soldiers kill those who defy, but at the same time he plays right into this to secure his own power. And the book doesn't hide it, doesn't pretend that he only acts out of goodness, doesn't pretend that he doesn't see where his actions are taking them. He might say: this is beyond me, I couldn't have stopped this - but he can, and he could. And he knows it.

This, I think, is one of the strengths of the book and one of the complexities - that you see, at the end of the book, a foreshadowing of a leader as brutal and bloody as the one they fought to overthrow. That you see a man drunk on his own power. That you, as the book closes, feels that all is NOT well. And that you almost already start fearing his reign.

Few books do this well. But this does so in both a beautiful, poignant and terrifying way. And therefore I cannot wait to read more. I just hope it continues to show that good intentions can still lead you to darkness, instead of elevating P to someone beyond good and evil.

Føler meg litt teit her, for jeg trodde først og fremst dette var et dataspill, som noen så hadde filmatisert, for videre å gi det ut i bokform for å melke suksessen fra spillet i det uendelige. Du vet, omtrent slik som med Jurassic Park.

Uansett, handlingen skal ligge en del tusen år frem i tid hvor en populær krydderblanding fører til en lang rekke forviklingar. Rett nok skal krydderblandingen ha en slags hallusinogen effekt, du vet, omtrent slik som med muskatnøtt.

Det er naturlig nok kamp om denne muskat-aktige krydderblandingen, ikke bare på kommunalt og nasjonalt nivå, nei her snakker vi interplanetarisk konfliktnivå. Heftige saker altså, du vet, litt slik som rockebandet We, et naturlig referansepunkt når en trekker frem hallusinogener og utenomjordiske reiser.

Boken starter med et oversiktskart, som nok må være noe av det mest uoversiktlige noengang forsøkt festet til et papir. Selv ikke når jeg var ferdig gav det særlig mening. De første kapitlene bidrar også godt til kaoset og gir pekere mot høyt konfliktnivå både i familie, kommune, stat, planet og univers. Heldigvis strammer den seg opp etter dette, og en begynner å se muligheter for å henge med i historien.

En må jo anerkjenne Herbert for høyt ambisjonsnivå, for til tross for relativt innfløkt opplegg er det en stram og lettfordøyelig historie han legger igjen. At en fjerdedel av boken også er vedlegg i form av essays og ordbok, vitner om at han legger til rette for spinoffs og ikke minst salg av store mengder merchandise.

Tenker at jeg i kveld kommer til å se ca fire sjettedeler av orginalfilmen, med innslag av litt frisbeegolf innimellom.

Eirik la ut lista over redaktørenes valg - her er tilsvarende liste over lesernes preferanser. Noe er likt, men ulikhetene er spektakulære. Rimeligvis er det engelskspråklige lesere som har gitt sine stemmer her - noen av de mest populære forfatterne har jeg aldri hørt om! Jeg har lest 37 av disse og har ingen ambisjoner om å lese hele lista!

Rangering fra 1 til 100. 138 anonyme medlemmer stemte på bøkene. Samlet 3. april 2014.

Nebula gir ut pris for beste roman i sjangeren fantasy/science fiction utgitt i USA forrige år, siden 1966. År 1982 er uten vinner. I 1967 og 1978 ble det kåret to vinnere. For hver bok står det hvilke bøker som var nominert. Kilden er her

De nominerte i 1982 var:
Little, Big by John Crowley
The Many-Coloured Land by Julian May
Radix by A A Attanasio
Riddley Walker by Russell Hoban

Bokserier som, etter min mening, holder god kvalitet gjennom hele serien, eller så lang i serien jeg har kommet.

The nation's best-loved novels - Top 100

Mommy Mannegren

2020 Reading Challenge
52 Books in 52 Weeks: mangla én bok her.

1. A book with the letter “W” in the title: «Przewalskis hest»
2. A hardcover: Zeyn Joukhadar - "Et kart av salt og stjerner"
3. By an indigenous author: Tommy Orange - "There there" (norsk tittel Powwow)
4. Set in winter: Naomi Novik - "Spinning silver"
5. A character who is a senior: Kathy Reichs - «Bones never lie» (moren til Brennan)
6. Written in the 1970’s: Carl Sagan - "Cosmos" (trolig, gitt ut i 1980)
7. An author local to you: Lars Saabye Christensen - "Byens spor"
8. Orange on the cover: Fredrik Backman - "Bjørnstad"
9. Set in space: Aliette Bodard - «On A Red Station, Drifting»
10. A bestseller: Jo Nesbø - "Kniv"
11. A book that leaves you thinking: Fredrik Backman - "Vi mot dere"
12. A “guilty pleasure”: Kathy Reichs - "Bones are forever"
13. Written by a female author: Erin Morgenstern - "The starless sea"
14. Book in a series: Robin Hobb - "Royal Assassin"
15. Book with romance: Agatha Christie - "Den åpne graven"
16. Borrowed from a friend: Sally Rooney - "Normal people"
17. Written by more than one author; Amir Levine; Rachel Heller - "Attached"
18. Published in 2020: Emma Lord - «Tweet Cute»
19. A Stephen King novel: Stephen King - «The stand»
20. An author whose last name starts with the same initial as yours: Leigh Bardugo - "Ninth house"
21. Written by a blogger or journalist: Rebecca Skloot - "The immortal life of Henrietta Lacks"
22. A character that frustrates you: Kathy Reichs - "Bones never lie" (Slidell, Brennan selv i blant)
23. Title beginning with A: Agatha Christie - "And Then There Were None"
24. Title beginning with B: Maja Lunde - "Blå"
25. Title beginning with C: Sayaka Murata - "Convenience Store Woman"
26. A strong “friendship” theme: Shobha Rao - "Girls burn brighter"
27. A comic book: Lise Myhre: «Nemi - Skumle damen»
28. Literary Fiction: Toni Morrison - "Beloved"
29. An award-winning novel: Taylor Jenkins Reid - "Daisy Jones & The Six" (Goodreads award best historical fiction, Glass bell award for fiction)
30. A book with recipes inside: Elizabeth Acevedo - "With the fire on high"
31. A book featuring royalty: Diana Gabaldon - «Dragonfly in Amber»
32. A spy novel: Brandon Sanderson - "Mistborn"
33. A book containing poetry: Diana Gabaldon - "Drums of autumn"
34. A book with illustrations: Lisa Aisato - «Livet - illustrert»
35. An author’s debut book: Alex Michaelides - "The silent patient"
36. Written in first person: Ransom Riggs - «Miss Peregrine’s home for peculiar children»
37. A book featuring the medical profession: Jodi Picoult - "A spark of light
38. Set in the future: Frank Herbert: - "Dune Messiah"
39. A book used in a celebrity book club: Delia Owens "Where the crawdads sing" (Reese's book club)
40. A book on the Mensa reading list for grades 9-12
41. Published when you were 20: Kij Johnson - "The cat who walked a thousand miles"
42. Reuse a prompt from a past year; Blake Crouch - "Dark Matter" (prompt: featuring time travel)
43. Set in a country you’ve never visited before: Kathy Reichs - "Bones of the lost" (USA og Afghanistan)
44. “Recommended” to you by Amazon: Samantha Shannon - «Priory of the orange tree»
45. A book that cost you less than $5: Andrzej Sapkowski - "The last wish"
46. By an author used in an earlier category: Lars Saabye Christensen - "Byens spor: Maj"
47. Story takes place on a form of transportation; Diana Gabaldon - "Voyager" (a bit of a stretch, men mye av handlinga foregår på skip)
48. Character who wears glasses: Abbi Waxman - "The bookish life of Nina Hill"
49. About a World Leader: Frank Herbert - "Dune" (Muad'Dib blir leder for planeten Arrakis)
50. An author you previously disliked: Suzanna Clarke - «Piranesi»
51. A genre you don’t normally care for: Bram Stoker - "Dracula"
52. A book with a Foreword: Sir Arthur Conan Doyle - "The adventures of Sherlock Holmes" (Audible-versjonen, med forord av Stephen Fry)

A book that's published in 2020: Susanna Clarke - "Piranesi"
A book by a trans or nonbinary author: Zeyn Joukhadar - «Et kart av salt og stjerner»
A book with a great first line: Fredrik Backman - "Bjørnstad". Linja er: "Sent en kveld i slutten av mars tok en tenåring en dobbeltløpet hagle i hånden, gikk rett ut i skogen, satte våpenet mot et menneskes panne og trakk av."
A book about a book club: Will Schwalbe . "The end of your life book club"
A book set in a city that has hosted the Olympics: Lars Saabye Christensen - "Byens spor" (Oslo)
A bildungsroman: Sally Rooney - «Normal people»
The first book you touch on a shelf with your eyes closed: Lise Myhre - «Nemi - Skumle Damen»
A book with an upside down image on the cover: Max Gladstone og Amal El-Mohtar - «This is how you lose the time war»
A book with a map: Robin Hobb - "Royal assasin"
A book recommended by your favorite blog/podcast/online book club: Jim Butcher - "Storm front"
An anthology: "The long list anthology: More stories from the Hugo award nominations list" (David Steffen, red.)
A book that passes the Bechdel test: Leigh Bardugo - "Ninth house"
A book with the same title as a show/TV show but is unrelated to it: Blake Crouch - "Dark Matter"
A book by an author with flora or fauna in their name: Jay Kristoff - "Nevernight"
A book about or involving social media: Emma Lord - «Tweet Cute»
A book that has a book on the cover: Abbi Waxman - "The bookish life of Nina Hill"
A medical thriller: Jodi Picoult - "A spark of light" (muligens litt tvilsom, men er en thriller satt til en medisinsk praksis (abortklinikk)
A book with a made-up language: Andrzej Sapkowski - "The last wish"
A book set in a country that starts with C: Margaret Atwood - «Alias Grace» (Canada)
A book you picked because the title caught your attention; Shobha Rao - "Girls burn brighter"
A book published the month of your birthday: Steven Erikson - «Gardens of the moon»
A book by or about a woman in STEM: Rebecca Skloot - "The Immortal Life of Henrietta Lacks"
A book that won an award in 2019: Taylor Jenkins Reid - "Daisy Jones & The Six"
A book on a subject you know nothing about: Amir Levine og Rachel Heller - "Attached" (visste ingenting om tilknytningspsykologi før dette)
A book with only words on the cover, no images: Jo Nesbø - "Kniv"
A book with a pun in the title: Kathy Reichs - "Bones are forever"
A book featuring one of the seven deadly sins: Diana Gabaldon - «Voyager» (lust, jealousy)
A book with a robot, cyborg, or AI: China Mieville - "Embassytown"
A book with a bird on the cover: William Shaw - "The birdwatcher"
A fiction or nonfiction book about a world leader: Frank Herbert - "Dune" (Muad'Dib er verdensleder på Arrakis)
A book with bronze, silver, or gold in the title: Naomi Novik - "Spinning silver"
A book by a WOC: Toni Morrison - "Beloved"
A book with at least four stars on Goodreads: Diana Gabaldon - «Dragonfly in amber»
A book you meant to read in 2019: Robert Jordan/Brandon Sanderson - "A memory of light"
A book with a three word title: Kathy Reichs - "Bones never lie"
A book with a pink cover: Delia Owens - "Where the crawdads sing"
A Western: Stephen King - "The gunslinger"
A book by or about a journalist: Jonas Hartford Sundquist - Upublisert manus/hemmelig (jeg er beta-leser)
Read a banned book during Banned Book Week: Bram Stoker - «Dracula»
Your favorite prompt from a past Popsugar challenge: A book with an LBTQ+ protagonist (2018): Erin Morgenstern - "The starless sea"

Advanced - a book written by an author in their 20's: Samantha Shannon - "Priory of the orange tree"
Advanced - a book with 20 or twenty in the title: Jules Verne - "20,000 leagues under the sea"
Advanced - a book with a character who has a vision impairment or enhancement: Frank Herbert - "Dune messiah"
Advanced - a book set in Japan: Kij Johnson - "The cat who walked a thousand miles"
Advanced - a book set in the 1920's: Agatha Christie - «Den åpne graven»
Advanced - a book by an author who has written more than 20 books: Agatha Christie - "And then there were none"
Advanced - a book with more than 20 letters in the title: Sir Arthur Conan Doyle - "The adventures of Sherlock Holmes"
Advanced - a book published in the 20th century: Stephen King - "The Stand"
Advanced - a book from a series with more than 20 books: Kathy Reichs - "Bones of the lost" (litt juks ettersom bok nummer 20 kommer til neste år. Men flere novellaer er skrevet i samme serie/univers også)
Advanced - a book with a character in their 20's: Diana Gabaldon - «Drums of autumn» (blant annet: Brianna, Roger, Stephen Bonnet)